Cocaine’s toxicity can be mitigated by blocking its interaction with sigma-1 receptors. The involvement of sigma-2 receptors remains unclear. To investigate their potential role, we have designed compounds through a convergent synthesis utilizing a highly selective sigma-1 ligand and elements of a selective sigma-2 ligand. Among the synthesized compounds was produced a subnanomolar sigma-2 ligand with an 11-fold preference over sigma-1 receptors. These compounds may be useful in developing effective pharmacotherapies for cocaine toxicity.